Hiring the first person in a European startup forces you to decide three things together: under what kind of relationship you have them work, what you promise them in equity and what it really costs you. These are three decisions where the mistake is paid for later, and where almost everything you read online is an industry habit and not a rule. This guide starts again from the rules. It explains from the text of the law how an employee is told apart from a contractor, which law applies to someone working in another country, what you must communicate in writing, what Italian law says about equity in startups and how the cost of a hire is built. It uses a program to calculate the vesting of options and the employer's cost, on invented data.
Employee, contractor or EOR: what the law decides
The first choice does not depend on the name you give the contract. In Italy article 2094 of the civil code (codice civile) defines an employee as someone who undertakes, for remuneration, to collaborate in the business by providing their work under the employment and direction of the entrepreneur. Article 2 of Legislative Decree (D.Lgs.) 81/2015 adds that the rules on employment also apply to collaborations that take the form of mainly personal, continuous work, the manner of execution of which is organised by the client. The same rule lists exceptions, among them the collaborations of those who practise intellectual professions for which registration in a professional register is required: if the person you want to involve is in one of those situations, a specific check is needed.
In practice the criterion is not the VAT number but the manner of working: who decides hours, place and organisation of the work. A contractor who works with imposed hours, and with the client's tools and coordination, risks being reclassified, with the consequences that the employment consultant can list and that I do not quantify. For the rest this guide does not distinguish between Italian contracts (open-ended, fixed-term, apprenticeship): they are choices regulated by law and by the applicable collective agreement, and have to be discussed with whoever manages them.
The employer of record (EOR) is a provider that becomes the formal employer of the person in the country where they work, while you direct the day-to-day activity and pay the provider. In the legal texts I read there is no European rule that defines it: it is a commercial model, and so what counts is what the contract with the provider says. That is why I give no commission figures and no number of countries covered: I have no primary source. One thing, however, is solid from the text of the regulation on the applicable law: the EOR does not change the country in which the person works, and the law applicable to the relationship depends on that country (see the next section). Before choosing an EOR, ask in writing:
- which legal entity signs the employment contract and under which law;
- who is liable in the event of a dispute or an inspection in the person's country;
- what happens to the relationship if the contract with you ends;
- whether and how the provider manages equity plans for the employees it hires;
- where the employee's personal data are kept and with what guarantees;
- which costs, besides the fee, are charged and under what conditions.
The six questions serve to move the discussion from the sales material to the contract: each asks you to put in writing a responsibility that would otherwise stay implicit. If an answer is vague, for you it is an unquantified risk; if it is precise, you have a clause to have your lawyer read.
Which law applies and what you must communicate in writing
When the person works in a country other than yours, the law of the employment contract follows European rules. Regulation (EC) 593/2008 ("Rome I"), in Article 8, says that an individual employment contract is governed by the law chosen by the parties, but that such a choice may not have the result of depriving the employee of the protection afforded by provisions that cannot be derogated from by agreement under the law that, in the absence of choice, would have been applicable. In the absence of choice the law of the country in which or, failing that, from which the employee habitually carries out his work applies; the country is not deemed to have changed if the employee is temporarily employed in another country. For a person working from home in another Member State, therefore, the clause "Italian law applies" is not enough to exclude the non-derogable rules of that country.
As for information, Directive (EU) 2019/1152 on transparent and predictable working conditions provides, in Article 4, that the employer informs the worker of the essential aspects of the employment relationship. Among those listed:
- the identities of the parties and the place of work;
- the title, grade, nature or category of the work, or a description of it, and the date of commencement;
- the duration and conditions of the probationary period, if any;
- the amount of paid leave and the procedure and notice periods for termination;
- the remuneration, with the initial basic amount, any other component elements, and the frequency and method of payment;
- the length of the standard working day or week and any arrangements for overtime;
- the collective agreements that apply;
- the social security institutions receiving the contributions, where it is the responsibility of the employer.
The list is a minimum and does not replace the contract, but it is a good checklist for your template employment letter: every missing item is something you will have to explain later. On the probationary period the directive (Article 8) says that it must not exceed six months, with the possibility of exceptions in particular cases; in Italy article 7 of D.Lgs. 104/2022, in the text in force from 12-1-2025, sets the same six-month limit, unless collective agreements provide a shorter duration, and lays down a proportional rule for fixed-term contracts.
Equity for collaborators: what Italian law says
Granting options or shares to collaborators is a common lever in startups, and in Italy it has a specific treatment for innovative startups. Article 27 of Decree-Law (D.L.) 179/2012 says, in summary, that the employment income arising from the assignment of financial instruments (or of rights providing for their attribution) to directors, employees or continuous collaborators, and from the exercise of option rights granted to acquire them, does not count towards the worker's taxable income, for tax and social security purposes, provided that the instruments are not bought back by the startup, by the issuing company or by related parties. If they are sold in breach of the condition, the income is taxed in the period in which the sale takes place. Capital gains on sale follow the ordinary regimes. The rule applies only to certified innovative startups and incubators: if your company is not one, it does not concern you, and the treatment of the options has to be asked of the accountant.
The no-buy-back condition deserves a question to a professional, because some exit clauses (the so-called leaver clauses) provide precisely for the company buying back the stake: how they interact with paragraph 1 I do not deduce myself. For srls (limited liability companies), article 26, paragraph 6, of the same decree establishes that for SME srls the prohibition on transactions in their own holdings (article 2474 of the civil code) does not apply if the transaction implements incentive plans that assign quotas to employees, collaborators or directors.
Vesting is the contractual mechanism by which equity vests over time; the law does not impose it, and the durations are chosen by whoever writes the plan. The program builds the simplest example, four years with a twelve-month cliff and monthly vesting, on 200,000 invented options with an exercise price of 0.50 euros, and also computes the gross gain if you exercised them, because it is easy to confuse the value of the share with the value of the option.
# INVENTED data: grant of 200,000 options, 4-year (48-month) vesting, 12-month cliff,
# monthly vesting after the cliff. Exercise price 0.50 EUR per share.
OPTIONS, MONTHS, CLIFF, STRIKE = 200_000, 48, 12, 0.50
def vested(months_of_service):
if months_of_service < CLIFF:
return 0
return OPTIONS * min(months_of_service, MONTHS) // MONTHS
def intrinsic_value(months_of_service, share_price):
"""Gross gain if you exercise all vested options: (price - strike) per option, never negative."""
return vested(months_of_service) * max(share_price - STRIKE, 0.0)
for m in (11, 12, 13, 24, 36, 48):
print(f"month {m:>2}: vested {vested(m):>7,}")
print("leaving at month 30, share price 2.00 EUR:", f"{intrinsic_value(30, 2.00):,.0f}", "EUR gross")
print("same options, share price 0.40 EUR :", f"{intrinsic_value(30, 0.40):,.0f}", "EUR gross")
# Independent check: a quarter vests at the cliff, and 1/48 per month after the cliff.
assert vested(12) == OPTIONS // 4
assert vested(13) - vested(12) == OPTIONS // MONTHS
assert vested(30) == 125_000
# Output: month 11: vested 0
# month 12: vested 50,000
# month 13: vested 54,166
# month 24: vested 100,000
# month 36: vested 150,000
# month 48: vested 200,000
# leaving at month 30, share price 2.00 EUR: 187,500 EUR gross
# same options, share price 0.40 EUR : 0 EUR gross
The first block of lines repeats the lesson of the cliff: in the first 11 months nothing vests, at the twelfth a quarter vests (50,000), and from there 1/48 per month (54,166 at month 13, rounded down). The second block shows the difference: leaving at month 30, with the share at 2.00 euros, the 125,000 vested options are worth (2.00 minus 0.50) times 125,000, that is 187,500 euros gross, not 125,000 times 2.00; and if the share is worth 0.40, below the exercise price, they are worth zero. It does not take into account taxes or any buy-back clauses: those are the subjects of the previous paragraph.
What a hire really costs
The cost to the company is the gross annual salary plus the employer's contributions plus the accrual of severance pay (trattamento di fine rapporto, TFR). Article 2120 of the civil code sets the TFR rule: for each year of service a share equal to the annual pay divided by 13.5 is set aside, proportionally reduced for fractions of a year, with a fraction of a month of 15 days or more counted as a full month. The employer's contribution rate, on the other hand, I did not read at the source: it depends on collective agreement, sector and company size, and has to be asked of the employment consultant. The program therefore treats it as a parameter, with three invented values, and shows the weight of the TFR.
from fractions import Fraction as F
# INVENTED data. Gross annual salary (RAL) of 36,000 EUR.
# The employer contribution rate is NOT read from a source: it is a parameter that you replace with
# the one from your employment consultant (it depends on collective agreement, sector, company size).
RAL = F(36_000)
# TFR (severance pay), article 2120 of the civil code (read): annual share = annual pay / 13.5,
# reduced for fractions of a year; a fraction of a month of 15 days or more counts as a full month.
def tfr_share(ral, whole_months, extra_days):
months = whole_months + (1 if extra_days >= 15 else 0)
return ral / F(27, 2) * F(months, 12)
def annual_cost(ral, employer_rate):
contributions = ral * employer_rate
tfr = tfr_share(ral, 12, 0)
return ral + contributions + tfr, contributions, tfr
def fmt(x):
return f"{float(x):,.0f}"
print("employer rate (parameter) | contributions | TFR | annual cost | above the RAL")
for rate in (F(25, 100), F(30, 100), F(35, 100)):
total, contributions, tfr = annual_cost(RAL, rate)
print(f"{float(rate):>24.0%} | {fmt(contributions):>13} | {fmt(tfr):>5} | {fmt(total):>11} | {float(total / RAL - 1):.1%}")
# An employment of 7 months and 20 days: the 20 days count as a full month
print("TFR for 7 months and 20 days:", round(float(tfr_share(RAL, 7, 20))), "EUR, against", round(float(tfr_share(RAL, 7, 14))), "EUR with 14 days")
# Independent check: annual TFR = RAL/13.5 = 2,666.67
assert tfr_share(RAL, 12, 0) == RAL / F(27, 2)
assert round(float(RAL / F(27, 2)), 2) == 2666.67
# Output: employer rate (parameter) | contributions | TFR | annual cost | above the RAL
# 25% | 9,000 | 2,667 | 47,667 | 32.4%
# 30% | 10,800 | 2,667 | 49,467 | 37.4%
# 35% | 12,600 | 2,667 | 51,267 | 42.4%
# TFR for 7 months and 20 days: 1778 EUR, against 1556 EUR with 14 days
With a gross salary of 36,000 euros, the annual TFR is 2,667 euros (36,000 divided by 13.5, and the check of the value is in the program) and the annual cost goes from 47,667 to 51,267 euros depending on the parameter, that is from 32% to 42% more than the gross salary. The result is not an estimate of what your hire will cost: it says that the cost to the company is a range, that the TFR alone is worth about 7.4% of the salary, and that the contribution rate communicated to you moves the total by a few thousand euros a year. Before setting a salary ask the consultant for the calculation with your collective agreement. Other European countries have different rules and rates: for each you need the source and the local consultant.
Candidate data and pay transparency
From the moment you receive a CV you process personal data, and Regulation (EU) 2016/679 gives you the rules. Article 5 requires that data be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary (data minimisation) and kept for no longer than is necessary for the purposes for which they are processed. Article 6(1) admits among the legal bases processing necessary in order to take steps at the request of the data subject prior to entering into a contract (point (b)) and the legitimate interests pursued by the controller, except where overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject (point (f)). Article 13 requires you to provide the data subject, at the time the data are obtained, with information on the controller, the purposes, the legal basis and the recipients. The regulation does not set a number of months for keeping the CVs of candidates who were not hired: set a term you can justify, write it in the privacy notice and respect it.
One novelty concerns pay. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency provides, in Article 5, that applicants have the right to receive from the prospective employer information about the initial pay or its range, based on objective, gender-neutral criteria, and that an employer must not ask applicants about their pay history during their current or previous employment relationships. Article 34 sets the transposition deadline at 7 June 2026. Italy transposed the directive with Legislative Decree of 7 May 2026, no. 96 (Gazzetta Ufficiale no. 125 of 1 June 2026, in force from 7 June 2026). Its article 5 provides that applicants be given indications of the initial pay or its range, in the notices and calls through which job opportunities are made known, and prohibits asking applicants about the pay received in current or previous employment relationships, including indirectly through whoever handles the selection.
Other obligations of the decree depend on the size of the company (article 6, paragraph 3, exempts from the criteria on pay progression employers with fewer than fifty employees): of the decree I read only these two articles, and how it applies to your job advert is for the employment consultant to establish.
Frequently asked questions
Can I hire a contractor with a VAT number instead of an employee?
You can, if the relationship is really self-employed. Article 2094 of the civil code and article 2 of D.Lgs. 81/2015 look at how the work is organised, not at the name of the contract: if the manner of execution is organised by the client and the work is mainly personal and continuous, the rules on employment apply. Have the employment consultant assess the case.
What is the maximum length of the probationary period?
Six months: so say Directive 2019/1152 (Article 8) and, in Italy, article 7 of D.Lgs. 104/2022, which refers to the shorter duration that collective agreements may provide. For fixed-term contracts the duration is proportional to the length of the contract.
Which law applies to someone working from another country?
If the parties do not choose, that of the country in which the work is habitually carried out (Article 8 of the Rome I Regulation). If they choose, the choice does not remove from the worker the non-derogable protections of the law that would have applied without a choice.
Can I ask a candidate how much they earn now?
Directive 2023/970 (Article 5(2)) says no, and provides for the candidate's right to know the initial pay or the range. In Italy the prohibition is in article 5 of D.Lgs. 96/2026, in force from 7 June 2026: ask the consultant how it applies to your advert.
What you can do now
You can tell from the law an employee from a contractor, and you know which questions to ask an EOR before signing. You can say which law governs the contract of someone working from another country, what the written communication must contain and how long a probationary period can last. You can calculate vesting and the value of options, you know that the equity of innovative startups has a specific treatment with a condition to check, and you can build the cost of a hire starting from the TFR. For the price of the product that funds the hires, read the guide to pricing and VAT; for the capital that comes from an investor and for the clauses that touch your equity, the one on the term sheet; for presenting it all to an investor, the one on the pitch.
Sources
- Directive (EU) 2019/1152 on transparent and predictable working conditions (EUR-Lex) - read on 2026-11-13 Articles 1, 4 and 8: information to be provided and maximum length of the probationary period.
- Regulation (EC) 593/2008, "Rome I" (EUR-Lex) - read on 2026-11-13 Article 8: law applicable to individual employment contracts.
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency (EUR-Lex) - read on 2026-11-13 Articles 5, 7 and 34 (transposition deadline 7 June 2026).
- Legislative Decree of 7 May 2026, no. 96, transposing Directive 2023/970 (Normattiva) - read on 2026-11-13 articles 5 and 6 and the date of entry into force (7 June 2026; GU no. 125 of 1 June 2026); the other articles were not read.
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679, GDPR (EUR-Lex) - read on 2026-11-13 Articles 5, 6 and 13.
- Italian civil code (Codice civile), arts. 2094 and 2120 (Normattiva); D.Lgs. 81/2015, art. 2 (text in force from 28-2-2023); D.Lgs. 104/2022, art. 7 (in force from 12-1-2025); D.L. 179/2012, arts. 26 (paragraph 6) and 27 - all read on 2026-11-13.
- Calculations: Python 3 programs reported above, run twice with identical output on 2026-11-13; the data are invented and the employer contribution rate is a parameter, not a value read at the source.

Commenti
Caricamento commenti...
Sign in to comment