Skip to main content

08 - Cursor vs Windsurf vs VS Code + Copilot in 2026

Cursor, Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) and Copilot compared on verifiable facts (rules, MCP, agents, costs), plus five criteria to choose with your own weights.

What do you think about this article?

08 - Cursor vs Windsurf vs VS Code + Copilot in 2026
Cursor IDEPhoto:Bibek ghoshPexels

At a Glance

Cursor, Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) and Copilot compared on verifiable facts (rules, MCP, agents, costs), plus five criteria to choose with your own weights.

A comparison that goes stale before it is read

If you search for "which is the best among Cursor, Windsurf and Copilot" you will find rankings with a winner. This article has none, for two reasons I checked today on the vendors' pages. The first: in six months the three products changed name, prices and the way usage is counted, so every ranking with numbers is already out of date. The second: "best" depends on weights that only you know, such as how much predictable cost matters, how much the GitHub workflow matters, how much control over data matters. Here you find the facts you can verify, with source and date, and a method to turn them into a choice of your own.

Three changes explain why the comparison is hard. Windsurf no longer exists under that name: the vendor's documentation says that from 2 June 2026 it became Devin Desktop, the same editor with a new name and with the Agent Command Center as the main view, and the old address windsurf.com now redirects to devin.ai. Copilot counts usage in monthly AI credits and no longer in premium requests. Cursor measures usage with a pool that renews every week. Three products, three units of measure: that is why a list-price comparison between "$20, $30 and $10" says almost nothing.

What is verifiable today, row by row

The table contains only information read on the three vendors' official pages on 2026-11-13: each cell carries the link to the page it comes from. Where a page did not say something, the cell does not claim it. The rows are the ones that change the daily work of someone developing in Angular or another web stack: where the persistent instructions live, how MCP servers are connected, where agents run, how usage is paid for.

DimensionCursorDevin Desktop (ex Windsurf)GitHub Copilot
What you install The Cursor application, with local and cloud agents The new name of Windsurf since 2 June 2026, the same editor with the Agent Command Center A GitHub service with clients in several editors (the MCP guide covers VS Code, JetBrains, Visual Studio, Eclipse, Xcode), CLI and app
Persistent instructions .cursor/rules/*.mdc with description, globs, alwaysApply, and AGENTS.md (source) .devin/rules/*.md with trigger, AGENTS.md, and import of .windsurf rules (source) .github/copilot-instructions.md, *.instructions.md files with applyTo, AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md, GEMINI.md (source)
MCP servers .cursor/mcp.json; stdio, SSE and Streamable HTTP transports (source) .devin/mcp_config.json; stdio, Streamable HTTP and SSE; approval required for every tool by default (source) File-based configuration or from the GitHub MCP Registry (public preview); for Business and Enterprise the "MCP servers in Copilot" policy is required, off by default (source)
Agents away from your computer Cloud Agents in isolated virtual machines (source) Devin Cloud, sold as a product separate from Desktop (source) "Copilot in the cloud", with a session in a sandbox or in an environment based on GitHub Actions, for paid plans from 28 October 2026 (source)
How usage is counted Shared pool that renews every week; third-party models at API rates (source) Quotas per plan; extra usage at API price on Pro (source) Monthly AI credits: in Pro 1,500 in total (1,000 base and 500 flexible) (source)
First paid plan, as of 2026-11-13 Plus $8 per month, Grok models only; Premium $30 Pro $20 per month Pro $10 per month

Read it by rows, not by columns. The first three show a convergence: all three read AGENTS.md and all three speak MCP, so the instructions and servers you prepare do not tie you to a product. If you write the project's rules in AGENTS.md instead of the proprietary format, changing tool costs much less. The rows on remote agents and on usage counting show the real differences instead: there the products are built differently and the choice weighs.

Why prices cannot be compared

The last row of the table is the least informative. The three amounts measure different things: Cursor includes a usage pool that renews weekly and bills third-party models separately at API rates, so the final spend grows with the model you choose; Copilot gives a monthly pool of credits and the plans page says how many each tier includes; Devin Desktop's Pro gives larger quotas and lets you buy extra usage at API price. The prices are the ones shown by the vendors, without taxes where the page says so (Cursor does). To really compare you need a measurement of your own: the same task run on each tool, with the consumption noted in that tool's unit and then translated into dollars.

Data and privacy: where to read, not what to believe

Here I chose not to summarize. On its security page (updated 25 August 2026) Cursor declares the ISO/IEC 27001:2022, ISO/IEC 42001:2023 and AIUC-1 certifications and the SOC 2 Type II attestation, and a Privacy Mode that can be turned on in settings or by the team administrator, with which it does not train on your data. For the other two the substance depends on the plan and the model used: GitHub describes it in its Trust Center and in the plan pages, Devin in its security page, which is the company's general page and is not specific to Desktop. If your code is subject to contractual constraints, the correct step is to ask the vendor in writing for the terms of your plan, not to trust a third-party summary.

The criteria to choose by

Instead of a winner, here are five criteria that take the comparison out of the abstract. They are not in order of importance: the order is decided by your weights, in the section that follows.

  • Quality of the agent on your code: how many steps it takes to complete a real task, how many corrections it asks for.
  • Predictable cost: how much the monthly spend varies between a quiet week and one of heavy use.
  • Integration with your workflow: whether you live on GitHub (issues, pull requests, Actions) or elsewhere.
  • Control over data: contractual terms, available settings and the constraints of your client.
  • Exit cost: how hard it is to leave (rules format, MCP configuration, team habits).

The fifth criterion is the one guides forget and the most useful when the market moves: the story of Windsurf, which became Devin Desktop with all the settings migrated by the company, shows that name and plans can change within a quarter. A project that has its rules in AGENTS.md and its servers in an MCP file moves in an afternoon, one built on a proprietary format much more slowly. For the format of Cursor's rules I refer you to the second article of the series.

Try for a week, with the same task

No table replaces a test on your own repository. The protocol is short, but it must be followed to the letter: the typical mistakes are changing the task between one tool and the other or not noting the consumption.

  1. Choose a real, bounded task, for example a dependency update or a new page with tests.
  2. Run the same task, from the same commit, on each tool in a different week or on a different branch.
  3. Note for each: total time, number of corrections you had to ask for, and consumption read in the interface.
  4. Reread the diff as in a review: count the defects found, not the speed at which it arrived.
  5. Translate consumption into an estimated monthly spend only at the end, with the rate shown by the vendor that day.

The order is part of the method: spend is converted last because the units change and because the rate is the one that counts on the day you decide. The fourth point protects against a frequent mistake, rewarding the tool that answers first but produces a diff to rewrite. If the task includes debugging, reuse the method from the previous article.

From measurements to choice: explicit weights

With ratings from 1 to 5 for each criterion, the next step is to multiply them by the weights and average. The script does it on invented numbers, declared as such in the comments, and has a single purpose: to show that with the same ratings the ranking changes if the weights change. I used two contexts, a small team of three developers with no constraints on data and a company with data review and a workflow entirely on GitHub.

# Ratings from 1 to 5, taken from a week of testing on the SAME task.
# The numbers below are INVENTED to show the method: they do not measure any real product.
PROVE = {
    "Tool A": {"agente": 5, "costo": 2, "github": 2, "dati": 3, "uscita": 4},
    "Tool B": {"agente": 3, "costo": 4, "github": 5, "dati": 5, "uscita": 3},
    "Tool C": {"agente": 4, "costo": 3, "github": 3, "dati": 2, "uscita": 4},
}

# The weights express how much each criterion matters TO YOU: they are the part no comparison can give you.
SCENARI = {
    "small team of three developers, no constraints on data": {
        "agente": 5, "costo": 2, "github": 1, "dati": 1, "uscita": 3,
    },
    "company with data review and a workflow entirely on GitHub": {
        "agente": 2, "costo": 2, "github": 4, "dati": 5, "uscita": 1,
    },
}


def punteggio(valutazioni: dict[str, int], pesi: dict[str, int]) -> float:
    return sum(pesi[c] * valutazioni[c] for c in pesi) / sum(pesi.values())


for scenario, pesi in SCENARI.items():
    classifica = sorted(PROVE, key=lambda s: (-punteggio(PROVE[s], pesi), s))
    print(scenario)
    for nome in classifica:
        print(f"  {nome}: {punteggio(PROVE[nome], pesi):.2f}")

# Output (python3 valutazione.py, Python 3.14.4; deterministic, identical in two runs):
# small team of three developers, no constraints on data
#   Tool A: 3.83
#   Tool C: 3.58
#   Tool B: 3.50
# company with data review and a workflow entirely on GitHub
#   Tool B: 4.43
#   Tool A: 2.93
#   Tool C: 2.86

The punteggio function is a weighted average: each rating multiplied by the criterion's weight, divided by the sum of the weights. The ratings are identical in the two scenarios, and the winner flips: Tool A, strong on the agent, wins in the first; Tool B, strong on data and integration, wins by a wide margin in the second. This is exactly why no general ranking is honest. The method's flaw is that the weights are subjective: the cure is to write them before the test and not after, so as not to adapt them to the result you wanted.

When to stay where you are, when to keep two

If you already use one of the three and have no problem you can name in a sentence, the cost of switching almost always outweighs the benefit. Switching makes sense when one of the five criteria has become a constraint: the monthly bill is no longer predictable, the client asks for data terms that your plan does not give, the workflow has moved to GitHub. Keeping two is a legitimate choice when the tasks differ, for example a strong agent for long tasks and a light assistant inside the editor you already use, provided you add the two costs instead of comparing them. For heavy use of agents in the project see the third article; for Copilot from the inside there is the dedicated series.

What you can do now

You know which facts about the three products are verifiable today and where, you know that Windsurf is now Devin Desktop and why price lists cannot be compared, and you have a one-week protocol plus an explicit-weights method to decide with your own data. The concrete step remains: prepare the rules in AGENTS.md and the servers in an MCP file, and apply it all to a real project in the last article of the series.

Frequently asked questions

Does Windsurf still exist?

Not as a name. According to Devin's documentation, from 2 June 2026 Windsurf became Devin Desktop: the same editor and the same features with a new brand and unchanged plans. Windsurf.com now redirects to devin.ai.

Which of Cursor, Windsurf and Copilot is the better choice?

It depends on five criteria that only you weigh: quality of the agent on your code, predictable cost, integration with GitHub, control over data and exit cost. Try the same task for a week on each and compare with weights written in advance.

Can I use the same rules in all three?

For the most part yes: the documentation of the three products says they read an AGENTS.md file in the project root. The proprietary formats (.cursor/rules, .devin/rules, .github/instructions) remain different.

The same series also includes Cursor IDE: The Complete Developer Guide.

Sources

The script was run with Python 3.14.4, twice, with identical output; the ratings inside are invented and only serve to show the method. I did not try or install any of the three products: every claim about the products comes from the official pages listed, in the version read on the date given. Prices and plans change often: recheck the vendor's page before deciding.

Try These Tools

Free developer tools related to this topic.

Commenti

Caricamento commenti...

Sign in to comment

New articles and tools on Telegram too

The Telegram channel flags the site's new articles and tools.

Did you like this article?

Explore other content on the blog or discover my projects